Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
40 Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Residential Property Management in Evansville, IN
Fetter Property-Management has been a trusted leader in residential property management for nearly four decades. Founded in 1986 and based in Evansville, Indiana, we serve property owners and tenants across Evansville, Newburgh, and surrounding areas. Our mission centers on delivering superior management services that protect investments, ensure tenant satisfaction, and foster professional vendor relationships. With a fully staffed team and 24/7 emergency services, we prioritize client needs through transparent communication and tailored solutions.

Backed by memberships in organizations like the Better Business Bureau and Property Owner & Managers Association, we combine local expertise with proven systems to maximize returns for over 100 property owners. Our comprehensive services include marketing, tenant screening, maintenance coordination, and financial reporting, all designed to simplify property ownership while maintaining high-quality standards.
Services
Property Management Tenant Screening Rent Collection Maintenance Services Financial Reporting HOA Management Property Sales Eviction Services Online Portals Marketing
Details
  • Year established: 1986
Highlights and features
  • We offer 40+ years of specialized property management experience in Indiana's rental market.
  • Our 24/7 emergency maintenance service ensures rapid response to urgent property needs.
  • We manage 500+ rental units for 100+ property owners using proven, efficient systems.
  • Our tenant screening process prioritizes quality over speed to protect your investment.
  • We provide transparent financial reporting with automated monthly statements and payments.
What people say
Timely communication Properly maintained properties Quick maintenance fixes Professional relationships 100% satisfaction
Services
Property Management
Our comprehensive property management services protect your investment through proactive maintenance, tenant relations, and financial oversight. We handle day-to-day operations including rent collection, vendor coordination, and lease enforcement while providing monthly performance reports. With 40 years of local market expertise, we maximize returns through strategic pricing and tenant retention programs.
Tenant Screening
We implement rigorous tenant screening to ensure quality occupancy. Our process includes credit checks, criminal background verification, employment confirmation, and rental history analysis while adhering to Fair Housing regulations. This thorough approach minimizes risks for property owners by identifying responsible tenants who will maintain properties and pay rent promptly.
Maintenance Services
Our dedicated maintenance team provides 24/7 emergency response and scheduled property upkeep. Services include repair coordination, turnover renovations, and preventive maintenance programs. We utilize trusted vendors to ensure quality workmanship while maintaining cost efficiency. Regular property inspections help identify issues before they become major problems, preserving asset value.
Financial Reporting
We offer transparent financial management with automated monthly reporting and secure fund transfers. Owners receive detailed statements covering income, expenses, and property performance metrics. Our system enables electronic payments while maintaining traditional check options. This comprehensive approach ensures property owners maintain full visibility over their investment's financial health.
Marketing
Our marketing strategy combines digital platforms with local market knowledge to attract qualified tenants. We optimize property listings with professional photography, virtual tours, and targeted online advertising. Competitive pricing analysis ensures rapid lease-up while maximizing rental income. Regular listing updates across multiple platforms maintain property visibility in Evansville's dynamic rental market.
Questions
What areas do you serve?
We serve Evansville, Newburgh, and surrounding areas in Indiana.
Do you allow pets?
Some properties accept pets with restrictions on breed, size, and quantity.
How do I apply for a rental?
Submit an online application through our portal with a $40 nonrefundable fee.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept online payments, money orders, and certified checks.
Do you offer 24/7 emergency services?
Yes, we provide 24/7 emergency maintenance support for urgent issues.
How long does application approval take?
Approval times vary but we prioritize complete applications with all required documents.
Reviews (6)
David Helton-Thompson
Mar 10, 2022 Report
Very friendly and info about the available properties was concise and informative. They have a great thing with the personal viewing of properties. Provide your info on the initial call to them and you receive a text or email with available times to tour locations pick your time. A few hours before that time another message will confirm followed by a message with a code for the location key box code. Enter code open box get a key. You have 2 hours to tour before code expires. When finished return key to box close it and all is done. No junk mail will follow or bothersome sales folks.
Zach Nichols
Oct 20, 2021 Report
Having been a contractor for Monty Fetter for a couple years it has been a great experience working with his property manager Heather and the man himself. After retirement a new woman Marcie Doty is taking over. A force to be reckoned with. Tough as nails but the least bit of professional in any way. She would rather scream than be professional and has a poor work ethic.
Amanda Myer
Aug 27, 2021 Report
I had one of the worst customer service experience with this company. I called in inquiring about a property this company had and spoke with Tiffani who is the most rudest person. She acted like it was a bother to answer my questions and was in a rush to get me off the phone. I have worked in customer service for many years and I am not typically the kind of person to post a review but she was ridiculous and doesn't need to work with the public or in customer service if she treats people like that. I will not be applying for a property now because of her and I can't imagine how she interacts with actual people who rent from this company!
Brandon Meredith
May 06, 2021 Report
Ever since I reached out in regards to my application, they have been great to work with. Every time I have an issue in my home, they usually respond within a day or 2. I have only lived in my house that I'm renting through them for a little over a month, but they have been great. They have also been very professional and always answer my questions. I know they have a bad reputation and I have been told they are "slumlords" but the home I live in is very nice and they have been great. Also live in a great neighborhood in a great part of town. The home is not cheap but I don't regret my decision to go through them. No complaints this far!
Stacie
Apr 05, 2021 Report
I rented from Fetter for over a year and I would NOT recommend anyone to rent from them. Their response time for maintenance is horrible. I needed multiple of things fixed in the apartment and they either took forever to fix them or only half way fixed them. The office is not professional nor will they keep you informed on what progress is being made or if they will even fix anything. My apartment was upstairs and my floor fell in in 3 different spots along with my ceiling falling in. It took them FOREVER to fix them and the floors is what broke me and caused me to move. Don't rent from them
Tarra Short
Nov 29, 2020 Report
I sent an email to Tiffany 12/16/2020 stating that I would not be renewing my lease. This email was sent via an already started conversation we had. I also talked to 2 different staff in the office about me getting the house ready for them to show to new tenants. Even letting them know I had filled holes in the walls and painted back over said holes, and bought new carpet for one of the rooms that had damaged carpet.

At no time was I told they had received my email to Tiffany. I have several emails back and forth with Tiffany and conveniently the only email she says she didn't get from we was the one I sent about not renewing my lease. I see other tenants with the same issue with the same woman. It sounds to me that she is conveniently losing these emails so the tenants will lose their deposit and be evicted so the company can claim more money they aren't entitled to.