Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Real Estate Partner in Carmel, CA
San Carlos Agency has been a family-owned and operated real estate and property management company since 1954. Our legacy of trust and integrity has made us the longest-serving sole family-owned property management company in Carmel, California. We prioritize client needs over sales pressure, offering personalized advice to help clients make informed decisions. With over 70 years of experience, we manage one of the largest housing inventories on the Monterey Peninsula, including vacation rentals, long-term rentals, and commercial spaces. Our vertically integrated approach allows us to assist with every stage of real estate transactions, from acquisition to property management.

Our team of licensed professionals specializes in investment properties and 1031 exchanges, leveraging deep local market knowledge. We maintain a reputation for fairness and honesty, resulting in satisfied clients who return and refer others. Our expertise spans Carmel-by-the-Sea, Carmel Highlands, Carmel Valley, Pebble Beach, Pacific Grove, and Monterey. We provide comprehensive asset management to maximize property value and investment returns. Contact us to experience the difference of working with Carmel's most established real estate experts.
Services
Real Estate Sales Property Management Vacation Rentals Long-Term Rentals Investment Properties
Details
  • Year established: 1954
Highlights and features
  • We have over 70 years of experience in Carmel real estate.
  • Our fourth-generation family ownership ensures personalized service.
  • We manage the largest local inventory of vacation and long-term rentals.
  • Our honest approach prioritizes client needs over sales pressure.
  • Expertise in 1031 exchanges and investment property management.
Associations and certifications
  • California Department of Real Estate
What people say
Honest approach Generational expertise Largest inventory Personalized service Long-term trust
Services
Real Estate Sales
We specialize in residential and investment property sales across the Monterey Peninsula. Our agents leverage deep market knowledge to help clients buy or sell homes for personal use or investment. With expertise in 1031 exchanges and vertical integration with property management services, we ensure seamless transactions and long-term asset value.
Property Management
Our comprehensive property management services cover maintenance, leasing, and financial oversight. We maximize returns through strategic improvements and tenant relations. With over 400 managed properties, we offer full-cycle management from acquisition to sale, ensuring property preservation and income optimization for owners.
Vacation Rentals
We manage an extensive inventory of furnished vacation homes in Carmel and surrounding areas. Properties include beachfront cottages and luxury homes near golf courses. Our booking system and local expertise ensure hassle-free stays, with pet-friendly options available across Scenic Road, Golden Rectangle, and Pebble Beach locations.
Long-Term Rentals
We offer unfurnished long-term rental homes and condos across the Monterey Peninsula. With over 300 properties in various price ranges, we help tenants find permanent housing solutions. Our services include property showings, lease management, and maintenance support for both landlords and residents.
Investment Properties
We assist clients in acquiring income-generating properties through 1031 exchanges and investment strategies. Our team provides market analysis, property selection, and management services. With decades of experience in Carmel's unique market, we help investors maximize returns while mitigating risks through diversified portfolio strategies.
People
Jack Britton
Broker
Fourth-generation leader with over 30 years of Carmel real estate experience. Licensed broker specializing in investment properties and 1031 exchanges. Committed to maintaining the company's legacy of integrity and personalized service.
James Pfeiffer
Managing Partner
Fourth-generation partner focused on property management operations. Oversees maintenance, accounting, and asset management teams. Brings technical expertise to ensure properties maintain value while meeting regulatory standards.
Questions
What areas do you serve?
We specialize in Carmel-by-the-Sea, Pebble Beach, Monterey, Pacific Grove, Carmel Valley, and Carmel Highlands.
Do you manage vacation rentals?
Yes, we manage over 400 properties including the largest inventory of Carmel vacation homes.
Are you a family-owned business?
Yes, we've been family-owned and operated since 1954 as the fourth-generation leaders.
Do you handle investment properties?
Yes, we specialize in 1031 exchanges and investment property management across the Monterey Peninsula.
What services do you offer?
We provide real estate sales, property management, vacation rentals, long-term rentals, and investment property services.
Videos
Reviews (7)
Eddie Miller
Jan 01, 2022 Report
Very professional, responsive and accommodating staff. Great vacation home options including their own maintenance coordinator in case any needs arise. Everyone has been so friendly, Natalie is awesome.
Isle A. D.
Apr 20, 2021 Report
We have been renting from San Carlos for over 20 years. They are excellent at what they do. Always so very nice and extremely professional. Truly a pleasure to rent Carmel vacation homes from them.
Joan Reid Lapuyade
Mar 19, 2021 Report
SCA is top drawer without being irritating. Such a nice group of people to work with, always there when you need them.
L. Kuhns
May 14, 2020 Report
I had the wonderful pleasure of buying a house in Pebble Beach with Jack Britton and James Pfeiffer of San Carlos Agency as my agents. They were so calm, logical, reasonable and effective that the whole process went very smoothly. They represented my interests very well, all the while keeping good feelings between me and the sellers, so that when the deal was completed both the sellers and I were very satisfied with the end result. Jack and James always got back to me quickly with thorough answers and explanations to my questions. They've lived around here so long that their opinions of value and real estate conditions seemed very accurate. If I buy or sell again, I will definitely use them as my agents again.
Bob C.
Oct 14, 2019 Report
We have been using San Carlos for at least 20 years for our yearly vacation rental service and they always come through for us. Any time we find an issue with a property they work quickly to fix it. Always with a smile!
Laura Kelly
Dec 27, 2018 Report
As a first time landlord, I knew I needed help staying within the laws and regulations and keeping my emotions in check. The guidance provided by San Carlos Agency has done that for me. Jack has been responsive, respectful and resourceful. He always gives me choices along with the well thought out advice he offers. I appreciate the way Jack has kept me focused on sensible solutions. I am also extremely grateful for the tremendous resources that San Carlos has connected me with.

They have a deep reservoir of quality contractors who provide high quality service for a reasonable price and get the job done in a timely manner, all with no mark up from San Carlos. Jack has even provided me with multiple bids on more than one occasion. If you want a professional with integrity, Jack at San Carlos is your man.
Patti H.
Nov 12, 2018 Report
San Carlos Agency gave me outstanding service in finding excellent long term tenants for my Carmel property. I live in SoCal and was able to totally rely on Jack and James to make sure every management, maintenance and repair issue was promptly and professionally resolved. They earned my trust so the Agency was the obvious choice when it came time to sell the house. They marketed the property and found a qualified buyer who was able to close the transaction quickly. Every detail of the sale was meticulously handled. I could not recommend the San Carlos Agency more highly. Patti Handfinger.